Condemnation for bishop who called for gay people to 'repent'
{
"requests": {
"pageView": "https://ssc.independent.co.uk/b/ss/indepdev/1/h.27.5./s4450766658417?c1=${c1}&c2=${c2}&c3=${c3}&c6=${c6}&c7=${c7}&c8=${c8}&c9=${c9}&c10=${c10}&c11=${c11}&c12=${c12}&c13=${c13}&c14=${c14}&c15=${c15}&c16=${c16}&c17=${c17}&c18=${c18}&c19=${c19}&c23=${c23}&c36=${c36}&c38=${c38}&pageName=${pageName}&h1=${h1}&ch=${ch}&events=${eventsa}&server=${server}&r=${documentReferrer}&z=RANDOM&reportSuiteID=${reportSuiteID}&c66=${articleType}&v66=${articleType}&c68=${userType}&v68=${userType}&c75=${userType}&v75=${userType}&c69=${isLoggedIn}&v69=${isLoggedIn}&c72=${shareType}&v72=${shareType}&c70=${uid}&v70=${uid}&c71=${registrationDate}&v71=${registrationDate}&c73=${demographics}&v73=${demographics}&c74=${socialSignInType}&v74=${socialSignInType}&events=${eventType}",
"galleryView" : "https://ssc.independent.co.uk/b/ss/indepdev/1/h.27.5./s4450766658417?c1=${c1}&c2=${c2}&c3=${c3}&c6=${c6}&c7=${c7}&c9=${c9}&c10=${c10}&c11=${c11}&c12=${c12}&c13=${c13}&c14=${c14}&c15=${c15}&c16=${c16}&c17=${c17}&c18=${c18}&c21=${c21}&c23=${c23}&c36=${c36}&c38=${c38}&pageName=${pageName}&h1=${h1}&ch=${ch}&events=${eventsg}&server=${server}&r=${documentReferrer}&z=RANDOM",
"inlineGalleryView" : "https://ssc.independent.co.uk/b/ss/indepdev/1/h.27.5./s4450766658417?c1=${c1}&c2=${c2}&c3=${c3}&c6=${c6}&c7=${c7}&c9=${c9}&c10=${c10}&c11=${c11}&c12=${c12}&c13=${c13}&c14=${c14}&c15=${c15}&c16=${c16}&c17=${c17}&c18=${c18}&c21=${c21}&c23=${c23}&c36=${c36}&c38=${c38}&pageName=${pageName}&h1=${h1}&ch=${ch}&events=${eventsg},${eventsi}&server=${server}&r=${documentReferrer}&z=RANDOM",
"linkTrack": "https://ssc.independent.co.uk/b/ss/indepdev/1/h.27.5./s4450766658417?${eventId}=${itemName}&pageName=${pageName}&pe=lnk_o&server=${server}&r=${documentReferrer}&z=RANDOM"
},
"vars": {
"pageName": "news/uk/home-news/article1732755",
"h1": "news,uk,home-news",
"ch": "news",
"c1": "news:uk",
"c2": "news:uk:home-news",
"c3": "",
"c6": "",
"c7": "",
"c8": "Article",
"c9": "1732755",
"c10": "11:00 PM",
"c11": "Condemnation for bishop who called for gay people to 'repent'",
"c12": "condemnation-for-bishop-who-called-for-gay-people-to-repent-1732755.html",
"c13": "By Lewis Smith",
"c14": "",
"c15": "image",
"c16": "Sunday, 5 July 2009",
"c17": "${queryParam(CMP)}",
"c18": "PWAMP Site",
"c19": "article",
"c23": "",
"c28": "Sunday, 23 October 2011",
"c21": "Gallery",
"c36": "AMP - stream5",
"c38": "Anglicanism,Churches,Church Of England,Rochester",
"eventsg": "event3",
"eventsi": "event14",
"eventsa": "event7",
"server": "www.independent.co.uk",
"cNext":".amp-carousel-button-next",
"cPrev":".amp-carousel-button-prev",
"userType": "anonymous"
},
"triggers": {
"pageLoad": {
"on": "visible",
"request": "pageView"
},
"clickTracking": {
"on": "click",
"selector": ".menu-link, .inline-readmore a, .inline-related a, .amp-list a",
"request": "linkTrack",
"vars": {
"prop": "${eventId}",
"type": "${itemName}"
}
},
"trackShareFacebook": {
"on": "click",
"selector": "amp-social-share[type=facebook]",
"vars": {
"shareType": "facebook",
"eventType": "event10"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackShareTwitter": {
"on": "click",
"selector": "amp-social-share[type=twitter]",
"vars": {
"shareType": "twitter",
"eventType": "event10"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackShareEmail": {
"on": "click",
"selector": "amp-social-share[type=email]",
"vars": {
"shareType": "email",
"eventType": "event10"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackShareWhatsapp": {
"on": "click",
"selector": "amp-social-share[type=whatsapp]",
"vars": {
"shareType": "whatsapp",
"eventType": "event10"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackLogout": {
"on": "click",
"selector": "a[href$=logout]",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event8"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackLogin": {
"on": "amp-form-submit-success",
"selector": "#form-login",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event9"
},
"request": "pageView"
}
,"trackComment": {
"on": "amp-form-submit-success",
"selector": "#post-comment-form",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event12"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackReplyComment": {
"on": "amp-form-submit-success",
"selector": "#reply",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event12"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackCommentMinds": {
"on": "amp-form-submit-success",
"selector": "#post-comment-form-minds",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event16"
},
"request": "pageView"
},
"trackReplyCommentMinds": {
"on": "amp-form-submit-success",
"selector": "#subscription-reply",
"vars": {
"eventType": "event16"
},
"request": "pageView"
}
}
}
{"vars":{"account":"UA-27212627-1"},"extraUrlParams":{},"triggers":{"defaultPageview":{"on":"visible","request":"pageview"}}}
{
"vars":
{ "c2": "10476312" },
"extraUrlParams":
{ "comscorekw": "amp" }
}
{
"vars": {
"pcode": "p-jAJ_WUYAnDzxn",
"labels": [" AMPProject","independent.news/uk/home-news/article1732755","independent.news","independent.news,uk,home-news","independent.condemnation-for-bishop-who-called-for-gay-people-to-repent-1732755.html","independent.","independent.11:00 PM","independent.news:uk:home-news","independent.image","independent.Anglicanism,Churches,Church Of England,Rochester" ]
}
}
{
"vars": {
"pubId": "759",
"siteId": "003"
}
}
.cls-1{fill:#e30d24;}.cls-2{fill:#fff;}
Created with Sketch.
Log in using your social
network account
Try Independent Minds
free for 14 days
See the options
Hi {{fullName}}
- My Independent Minds
- Account details
- Help centre
- Logout
{ defaultRegScreenSet: '', defaultMobileRegScreenSet: '' };
Condemnation for bishop who called for gay people to 'repent'
Michael Nazir-Ali accused of pandering to hate and homophobia
GETTY/UPPA
The Bishop of Rochester has been accused of pandering to hate and homophobia after calling on homosexuals to repent. Michael Nazir-Ali provoked outrage among gay groups when he urged Church leaders to stick to traditional values instead of being swayed by "culture and trends".
While calling for the "traditional teaching" of the Bible to be upheld, the Bishop said of homosexuals: "We want them to repent and be changed."
His controversial remarks were published just hours after more than half a million people, including the Prime Minister's wife, Sarah, took part in the Gay Pride parade in London.
Sharon Ferguson, of the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement, condemned Dr Nazir-Ali for making comments that she said would encourage hatred.
"It feeds to the more fundamental individuals who are looking to have their opinions ratified and speak hatefully and behave hatefully," she said.
"His comments are likely to cause more of a schism within the Church of England. He's saying their [gays and lesbians] sexuality is a sin. It's not. It's a gift from God. God made us all."
She added: "He is telling people 'You have to repent' for something they have no control over. It's like asking someone to repent because they have blue eyes."
Peter Tatchell, the gay rights campaigner, said he was "shocked" at the level of anti-gay prejudice voiced by the bishop. "Homophobia is a social and moral evil, just like racism. Bigotry, even in the guise of religion, has no place in a compassionate, caring society," he said. "I call on the bishop to repent his homophobia. His prejudice goes against Christ's gospel of love and compassion."
Labour MEP Michael Cashman accused the Bishop of Rochester of being "selective" about which parts of the Bible he upheld. "When he calls for the closure of all the banks, finance houses and credit card companies because of what it says in the Bible about usury, then I'll take him seriously," he said. "Until then, unless he can say anything good, he should shut up."
In his comments, made to a Sunday newspaper, the bishop said homosexuals should be welcomed into the Church but that a person's sexual nature could only be correctly expressed in a heterosexual union within marriage. His remarks reopened the row over homosexuality that has for years threatened to tear the Anglican Church apart.
He made them on the eve of today's official launch of the Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans at Westminster Central Hall in London where he is expected to speak in support of the organisation. The UK branch of the Fellowship is regarded by many liberals within the Anglican movement as an attempt to create a church within a church with the aim of heading off moves to ease rules on homosexuality. Dr Nazir-Ali is to step down in the autumn and he is expected to play an important part in the Fellowship's activities.
The Very Rev Colin Slee, the Dean of Southwark and a prominent liberal, was so alarmed by the the impending departure of Dr Nazir-Ali from the See of Rochester that he described it as "clearly a move towards a sectarian alternative church intentionally designed to create turbulence in the Anglican Communion".
Canon Chris Sugden, of the Fellowship, said a message from the Queen will be read out during the ceremony but a Buckingham Palace spokeswoman called it nothing more than a "standard response" to the many requests made to the monarch each year. "It isn't endorsing anyone's point of view," she said.
Zeal of the convert: The Bishop of Rochester
*Michael Nazir-Ali has been one of the most vocal and controversial of bishops of the past decade and has rarely been afraid to speak out.
He was a leading contender to become Archbishop of Canterbury when George Carey stood down but has found himself at odds with Rowan Williams, the incumbent.
The issue of homosexuality has been one of the biggest causes of friction between Dr Nazir-Ali, the Bishop of Rochester, and the liberal wing of the Anglican Church.
In 2008 the rift was so marked that he boycotted the Lambeth Conference, a meeting of Anglican Church leaders held once a decade, because of the row over homosexuality. He is part of an evangelical wing urging the Church to stick to a traditional interpretation of the scriptures regarded by liberals, especially on the issues of homosexuality and women priests, as backward.
This year he announced he would step down as Bishop of Rochester in September to allow him time to concentrate on representing the Church in parts of the world where Anglicans are a minority religion or oppressed.
Born in Pakistan to Catholic parents, he converted at the age of 20 and holds dual British and Pakistani nationality. Appointed the 106th Bishop of Rochester in 1994, he was the first non-white diocesan bishop in the Church of England. Since then he has been a frequent critic of the rise of Islam in Britain.
{
"flaggedComments": ,
"selectedTab": "minds",
"feedUrl": "/article-comments/1732755",
"showAll": "",
"sortQuery": "dateDesc",
"feedUrl_p": "/article-comments/1732755_p",
"showAll_p": ""
}
<!--
Independent News Email
Only the best news in your inbox
-->
return function (urls, resolve, reject, id) {
if (typeof Promise === 'undefined') return;
var promises = urls.map(url => {
return new Promise(function (ok, error) {
var element = document.createElement('script');
var parent = 'head';
var attr = 'src';
element.onload = ok;
element.onerror = error;
if (id && id !== 'undefined') {
element.id = id;
}
element.async = 'async';
element[attr] = url;
document[parent].appendChild(element);
});
});
return Promise.all(promises).then(resolve, reject);
};
})();esi_loader(["/subscriber/premium.js?r=1542071144877"], function () {
var tp = window['tp'] || ;
var tags = ;
const _userRef = window._userRef;
_userRef && tp.push(['setUserRef', _userRef]);
tp.push(['setContentCreated', globals.publishDate]);
tp.push(['setContentAuthor', globals.primaryAuthor]);
tp.push(['setContentSection', globals.channel]);
tp.push(['addHandler', 'checkoutCustomEvent', function (event) {
if (event && event.eventName === 'offer-close-modal') {
const footerPrompt = document.getElementById('footerPrompt');
if (footerPrompt) {
footerPrompt.classList.add('hide')
}
}
}]);
globals.isCommercial && tags.push('commercial');
globals.isPremiumArticle && tags.push('premium');
globals.contentType && tags.push(globals.contentType);
globals.topictags && tags.concat(globals.topictags);
tp.push(['setTags', tags]);
tp.push(['init', function() {
window.tp.enableGACrossDomainLinking();
}]);
window.tp = tp;
esi_loader([globals.pianoScript], function () { })
}, null, 'undefined');
!function() {
const getCookie = function(name) {
const value = "; " + document.cookie;
const parts = value.split("; " + name + "=");
if (parts.length == 2) return parts.pop().split(";").shift();
};
const loggedIn = getCookie('lgd_n');
const subscriber = getCookie('subscriber')
var chartbeatUid = 62356;
var domain = 'independent.co.uk';
if (globals.authors) {
var authors = globals.authors;
} else {
authors = '';
}
var brightcovePlayer = 'players.brightcove.net';
if (globals.cbSections) {
var path = location.pathname;
var title = globals.title;
var sections = globals.cbSections;
if (path.indexOf('/go/london/list') >= 0) {
sections = path.replace('/go/london', '');
title = 'GO AutoList: ' + sections;
sections = sections.replace(/\//g,',go-list-');
sections = sections.substr(1);
} else if (path.indexOf('go/london/search') >= 0) {
sections = 'GO Search';
title = 'GO Search';
}
window._sf_async_config = {};
const _sf_async_config = window._sf_async_config;
_sf_async_config.uid = chartbeatUid;
_sf_async_config.domain = domain;
_sf_async_config.useCanonical = true;
_sf_async_config.useCanonicalDomain = true;
_sf_async_config.flickerControl = false;
_sf_async_config.title = title;
_sf_async_config.sections = sections;
_sf_async_config.authors = authors;
_sf_async_config.playerdomain = brightcovePlayer;
var _cbq = window._cbq = (window._cbq || );
if (domain === 'independent.co.uk') {
if (loggedIn && subscriber) {
_cbq.push(['_acct', 'paid']);
} else if(loggedIn) {
_cbq.push(['_acct', 'lgdin']);
} else {
_cbq.push(['_acct', 'anon']);
}
if (globals.contentType === 'article') {
_sf_async_config.sections = 'type-article-' + (globals.isPremiumArticle ? 'premium' : 'non-premium') + ',' + _sf_async_config.sections;
}
} else {
if (loggedIn) {
_cbq.push(['_acct', 'lgdin']);
}
}
}
}();
esi_loader(["https://tags.crwdcntrl.net/c/12699/cc.js?ns=_cc12699"], function() {
_cc12699.bcp();
}, null, 'LOTCC_12699');var js_loaded=false;var captify_kw_query_11667 = '';esi_loader(["//ak.sail-horizon.com/spm/spm.v1.min.js"], function () {
Sailthru.init({ 'customerId': 'cda4d6f939d454253e8b71957a096855' });
}, null, 'undefined');
Comments
Share your thoughts and debate the big issues
Learn more
Open Comments
Join the discussion
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
Newest first
Oldest first
Most liked
Least liked
{{^comments}}
{{/comments}}
{{#comments}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
Reply
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{#replies}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
Reply
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{#replies}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{/replies}}
{{/replies}}
{{/comments}}
{{#showMore}}
{{/showMore}}
Minds Comments
Join the discussion
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
Community Guidelines
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
Newest first
Oldest first
Most liked
Least liked
{{^comments}}
{{/comments}}
{{#comments}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
Reply
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{#replies}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
Reply
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{#replies}}
{{sender.name}}
{{dateTime}}
{{#sender.isSelf}}
Delete
{{/sender.isSelf}}
{{posVotes}}
<!--
-->{{negVotes}}
-1 ) ? 'vote-flagged' : ''">
<!--
-->
{{/replies}}
{{/replies}}
{{/comments}}
{{#showMore_p}}
{{/showMore}}
Follow comments
Vote
Report Comment
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 14 days.
Already registered? Log in
Report Comment
Delete Comment
Register to The Independent to comment
Anyone can post in open comments. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.
Already registered? Log in
Reply
Subscribe to Independent Minds to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Try Independent Minds free for 14 days.
Already registered? Log in
Reply
About The Independent commenting
Independent Minds Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Minds.
It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss
real-world solutions, and more. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when
they can to create a true meeting of independent minds. The most insightful comments on all subjects
will be published daily in dedicated articles. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies
to your comment.
The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to
Independent Minds. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post
the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Please
continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.
Already registered? Log in