Skip to main content






try{(function(isVeryModern,document,window){if(isVeryModern){var decodeBase64=function(str){return decodeURIComponent(atob(str.replace(/-/g,"+").replace(/_/g,"/").replace(/,/g,"x3d")))};var cookieData=function(a){var d=,e=document.cookie.split(";");a=RegExp("^\s*"+a+"x3d\s*(.*?)\s*$");for(var b=0;b0)return d[0];return null}("GU_U");var userData=cookieData?JSON.parse(decodeBase64(cookieData.split(".")[0])):null;if(userData){var displayName=decodeURIComponent(userData[2]);window.guardian.config.user={id:userData[0],displayName:displayName,accountCreatedDate:userData[6],emailVerified:userData[7],rawResponse:cookieData}}}})(guardian.isEnhanced&&"atob"in window,document,window)}catch(e){};try{(function(document,window){if(typeof window.getComputedStyle!=="function")return;var ad=document.createElement("div");ad.style.position="absolute";ad.style.left="0";ad.style.top="0";ad.style.height="10px";ad.style.zIndex="-1";ad.innerHTML="x26nbsp;";ad.setAttribute("class","ad_unit");window.requestAnimationFrame(function(){document.body.appendChild(ad);window.requestAnimationFrame(function(){var adBlockers=window.guardian.adBlockers;var adStyles=window.getComputedStyle(ad);var displayProp=adStyles&&adStyles.getPropertyValue("display");var mozBindingProp=adStyles&&adStyles.getPropertyValue("-moz-binding");adBlockers.active=displayProp==="none"||mozBindingProp&&mozBindingProp.indexOf("about:")!==-1;runEachListener(adBlockers.onDetect);adBlockers.onDetect={push:function(){var toRun=Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments,0);runEachListener(toRun)}};function runEachListener(listeners){for(var i=0;i<listeners.length;i++)try{listeners[i](adBlockers.active)}catch(e){}}})})})(document,window)}catch(e){};try{(function(isVeryModern,document,window){var user=window.guardian.config.user;if(isVeryModern&&user)window.requestAnimationFrame(function(){var $profileInfoElem=document.getElementsByClassName("js-profile-info")[0];var $profileNavElem=document.getElementsByClassName("js-profile-nav")[0];if(!$profileInfoElem&&!$profileNavElem)return;$profileInfoElem.innerHTML=user.displayName;$profileNavElem.classList.add("is-signed-in");var $signInLinkElem=$profileNavElem.getElementsByTagName("a")[0];if($signInLinkElem)if(user.id)$signInLinkElem.addEventListener("click",function(e){e.preventDefault()});else $signInLinkElem.setAttribute("href",$signInLinkElem.getAttribute("href").replace("signin","public/edit/"));var $register=document.getElementsByClassName("js-profile-register");if($register.length){$register=$register[0];$register.parentElement.removeChild($register)}})})("classList"in document.documentElement,document,window)}catch(e){};try{(function(document,window){if(!window.__cmp)window.__cmp=function(){var listen=window.attachEvent||window.addEventListener;listen("message",function(event){window.__cmp.receiveMessage(event)},false);function addLocatorFrame(){if(!window.frames["__cmpLocator"])if(document.body){var frame=document.createElement("iframe");frame.style.display="none";frame.name="__cmpLocator";frame.setAttribute("aria-hidden",true);document.body.appendChild(frame)}else setTimeout(addLocatorFrame,5)}addLocatorFrame();var commandQueue=;var cmp=function(command,parameter,callback){if(command==="ping"){if(callback)callback({gdprAppliesGlobally:!!(window.__cmp&&window.__cmp.config&&window.__cmp.config.storeConsentGlobally),cmpLoaded:false})}else commandQueue.push({command:command,parameter:parameter,callback:callback})};cmp.commandQueue=commandQueue;cmp.receiveMessage=function(event){var data=event&&event.data&&event.data.__cmpCall;if(data)commandQueue.push({callId:data.callId,command:data.command,parameter:data.parameter,event:event})};cmp.config={storeConsentGlobally:false,storePublisherData:false,logging:false,gdprApplies:false};return cmp}()})(document,window)}catch(e){};try{(function(document,window){function shouldServeLotame(){try{var geo=JSON.parse(window.localStorage.getItem("gu.geolocation")).value;if(geo==="US"||geo==="CA"||geo==="AU"||geo==="NZ")return false;return true}catch(e){}return false}if(shouldServeLotame()){var script=document.createElement("script");script.src="https://tags.crwdcntrl.net/c/12666/cc.js";document.body.appendChild(script)}})(document,window)}catch(e){};(function(window,document){function getCookieValue(name){var nameEq=name+"x3d",cookies=document.cookie.split(";"),value=null;cookies.forEach(function(cookie){while(cookie.charAt(0)===" ")cookie=cookie.substring(1,cookie.length);if(cookie.indexOf(nameEq)===0)value=cookie.substring(nameEq.length,cookie.length)});return value}window.guardian.config.ophan.browserId=getCookieValue("bwid")})(window,document);const pillar='';(function(){function convertContentType(contentType){var result=contentType;if(typeof contentType==='string'){result=contentType.toLowerCase().split(' ').join('');}return result;}function getQueryParam(key){var query=window.location.search.substring(1);var vars=query.split("&");var pairs=vars.map(function(x){return x.split('=')});return pairs.filter(function(xs){return xs.length==2&&xs[0]==key}).map(function(xs){return xs[1]})[0];}function getAnalyticsEdition(){var edition=(guardian.config.page.edition||'').toLowerCase()
return edition==='int'?'international':edition;}function getAnalyticsTitle(){var analyticsTitle=(guardian.config.page.webTitle||'');return(analyticsTitle==='Network Front')?getAnalyticsEdition()+' network front':analyticsTitle;}function getExperienceValue(){return'none';}var identityId=null;if(guardian.config.user){identityId=guardian.config.user.id;}var isLoggedIn=(!!identityId).toString();(function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){i['GoogleAnalyticsObject']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){(i[r].q=i[r].q||).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)})(window,document,'script','//www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js','ga');ga('create','UA-78705427-1','auto','allEditorialPropertyTracker',{'sampleRate':100,'siteSpeedSampleRate':0.1,'userId':identityId});ga('create','UA-33592456-1','auto','guardianTestPropertyTracker',{'sampleRate':5,'siteSpeedSampleRate':0.1,'userId':identityId});ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','forceSSL',true);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','title',getAnalyticsTitle());ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','anonymizeIp',true);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension1',guardian.config.ophan.pageViewId);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension2',guardian.config.ophan.browserId);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension3','theguardian.com');ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension4',guardian.config.page.section);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension5',convertContentType(guardian.config.page.contentType));ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension6',guardian.config.page.commissioningDesks);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension7',guardian.config.page.contentId);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension8',guardian.config.page.authorIds);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension9',guardian.config.page.keywordIds);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension10',guardian.config.page.toneIds);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension11',guardian.config.page.seriesId);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension15',identityId);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension16',isLoggedIn);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension21',getQueryParam('INTCMP'));ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension22',getQueryParam('CMP_BUNIT'));ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension23',getQueryParam('CMP_TU'));ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension26',(!!guardian.config.page.isHosted).toString());ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension27',navigator.userAgent);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension29',window.location.href);ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension30',getAnalyticsEdition());ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension43',getExperienceValue());ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','dimension50',pillar);if(document.location.hash==='#fbLogin'){ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.set','referrer',null);document.location.hash='';}ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','forceSSL',true);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','title',getAnalyticsTitle());ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','anonymizeIp',true);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension1',guardian.config.ophan.pageViewId);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension2',guardian.config.ophan.browserId);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension3','theguardian.com');ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension4',guardian.config.page.section);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension5',convertContentType(guardian.config.page.contentType));ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension6',guardian.config.page.commissioningDesks);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension7',guardian.config.page.contentId);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension8',guardian.config.page.authorIds);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension9',guardian.config.page.keywordIds);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension10',guardian.config.page.toneIds);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension11',guardian.config.page.seriesId);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension15',identityId);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension16',isLoggedIn);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension21',getQueryParam('INTCMP'));ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension22',getQueryParam('CMP_BUNIT'));ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension23',getQueryParam('CMP_TU'));ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension26',(!!guardian.config.page.isHosted).toString());ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension27',navigator.userAgent);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension29',window.location.href);ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension30',getAnalyticsEdition());ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension43',getExperienceValue());ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','dimension50',pillar);if(document.location.hash==='#fbLogin'){ga('guardianTestPropertyTracker.set','referrer',null);document.location.hash='';}ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.send','pageview',{hitCallback:function(){var image=new Image();image.src="//phar.gu-web.net/count/pvg.gif";}});try{var NG_STORAGE_KEY='gu.analytics.referrerVars';var referrerVarsData=window.sessionStorage.getItem(NG_STORAGE_KEY);var referrerVars=JSON.parse(referrerVarsData);if(referrerVars&&referrerVars.value){var d=new Date().getTime();if(d-referrerVars.value.time<60*1000){ga('allEditorialPropertyTracker.send','event','Click','Internal',referrerVars.value.tag,{nonInteraction:true,dimension12:referrerVars.value.path});}window.sessionStorage.removeItem(NG_STORAGE_KEY);}}catch(e){}guardian.app&&guardian.app.mediator&&guardian.app.mediator.emit('modules:ga:ready');})();


var _comscore=_comscore||;_comscore.push({c1:"2",c2:"6035250",comscorekw:guardian.config.page.keywords});(function(){var s=document.createElement("script"),el=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];s.async=true;s.src="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/beacon.js";el.parentNode.insertBefore(s,el);})();





!function(e,t,n,s,u,a){e.twq||(s=e.twq=function(){s.exe?s.exe.apply(s,arguments):s.queue.push(arguments);},s.version='1.1',s.queue=,u=t.createElement(n),u.async=!0,u.src='//static.ads-twitter.com/uwt.js',a=t.getElementsByTagName(n)[0],a.parentNode.insertBefore(u,a))}(window,document,'script');twq('init','nyl43');twq('track','PageView');